Open End vs Close End Leases: All You Need to Know

The concept of commercial vehicle leasing involves an organization leasing one or more vehicles, for a fixed amount of time, at an agreed amount of money. The monthly payment is calculated by assessing the vehicle’s value by the end of the lease term – this is referred to as the residual value. There are two types of leasing, open-end and closed. Each type has its own benefits which can be dependent on which option works for your organization.

Learn more below.

Open-End Leases

Open-end leases are a popular option due to their flexibility. This leasing option allows the opportunity for an organization as close to owning the vehicle without purchasing it outright. Generally, terms for an open-end lease include a fixed length of time (usually 12 months), followed by a month-to-month lease structure with no restrictions on mileage or penalties. After the minimum lease term has been met, vehicles can be returned or remarketed.

Benefits and Considerations of an Open-End Lease

  • This option is good for organizations whose fleet needs constantly change (project size, additional vehicles needed, etc.)
  • Heavy-duty usage can often affect the value of the vehicle, as it includes using vehicles to haul objects (constant wear and tear) or modifying the vehicle (adding equipment, load) for projects. An open-end lease helps avoid additional fees if usage includes utility vehicles, light to medium-duty vehicles or special equipment.
  • Great for heavy and rough usage. In open-end leases, there aren’t set limitations around damage, making it easier for projects of high mileage, heavy loads, and off-road conditions.

With this lease option, it is important for organizations to know that they will be responsible for the book value of the vehicle – market vs. residual. When organizations consider open-end leasing, there is potential to owe money or receive compensation at the end of their term. This is known as the Terminal Rental Adjustment Clause (TRAC).

Close-End Leases

Close-end leases are like most retail vehicle leasing programs – structured with set lengths, ranging from 12 to 72 months. At the end of the leasing term, organizations can return the vehicle or purchase for a set value. Organizations will not have to pay more than the agreed payments unless there are fees for excessive mileage and damage. In this structure, the leasing organization assumes the vehicle’s depreciation risk and will be responsible for the difference between the market value upon return and the residual value.

More Benefits and Considerations of a Close-End Lease

  • Closed-end leases are a great option for organizations that have stricter budgets and consistent needs, such as:
    • Steady and predictable daily operations
    • Set estimate of driver mileage*
    • Little or average wear from vehicle usage

*Based on the lease agreement, there may be additional mileage options available to provide flexibility for organizations.

Finances

Open-end leases can potentially incur additional costs (or credit) depending on the condition and value; closed end leases have a set leasing agreement with no immediate unexpected costs unless the vehicle is driven past the contract mileage limit, has damage, or needs repairs beyond "normal wear and tear" at the end of the lease

Fleet Size

How many vehicles do you want to lease? How diverse will your fleet vehicles (light to medium duty, sedans, etc.) be? These are just a couple of things to consider as you choose which leasing option will be the most effective for your organization

Flexibility

Are your fleet operations consistent? Then, a closed end lease option may be the best option. Or are there constant changes? If so, an open-end lease may better suit your fleet operations.

Mileage

Does your mileage vary (open-end) or is it consistent (close end)?

Usage
Patterns

Do you often operate in off-road conditions? If so, open-end lease would be the best option.

Customizations

Would you need to use heavy equipment? If so, open-end lease may be the better option but remember that altering the vehicle can affect the resale value.

What’s Next? How Enterprise Fleet Management Can Help:

We’re here to help you find the right solution that matches your business and operational needs.

If you...

Are looking to lease 20 or more light or medium-duty (Class 1-5) vehicles that will help drive your business, then look no further! Get started by filling out our Enterprise Fleet Consultation Form, and one of our fleet experts will be in touch to find a solution tailored for you.

If you...

Are looking for light or medium duty (Class 2b-6) vehicles for short and/or long-term business needs, you can get started by filling out our Enterprise Truck Rental Inquiry Form, and a specialist from our truck team will reach out to assist you further.

Contributor

Kelley Hatlee has worked in the vehicle service and fleet management industries for over 25 years. Holding a Bachelor of Science in Applied Management with Emphasis in Fleet Management degree from Ranken Technical College, he has served as a chapter officer in National Association of Fleet Administrators (NAFA) Fleet Management Association and has earned NAFA’s Certified Automotive Fleet Specialist (CAFS) certification. In 2017, Hatlee received the prestigious Automotive Care Alliance (ACA)/Automotive Service Excellence (ASE) World Class Technician Award, and Enterprise Fleet Management’s Fleet Operations Exceptional Performance Award in 2018. He has written and contributed to numerous articles for fleet industry publications and has presented fleet maintenance-related topics at industry conferences at the regional and national levels.​

Kelley Hatlee, Senior Service Advisor - Enterprise Fleet Management